I've always liked studying the evolution of properties. But I’ll admit to a particular fascination with golf course real estate.

I’m not sure exactly when that began. However, I do know I thoroughly enjoyed my hands-on research for The Trump Factor, which I published in 2016.

Don’t get me wrong. It was a lot of work and, since I self-published, a lot of money as well. But I did get to visit – and play – at every golf course Trump owned while I explored his properties firsthand as the real estate investments they are.

Championship golf courses can take up hundreds of acres of valuable land between the actual courses and attached amenities. Hotels, spas, retail shops, restaurants: They’re entire ecosystems unto themselves.

Seeing that up close and personal helped me further appreciate what it means to own these properties, including the enormous capital expenditures necessary to develop and maintain them. Yet I still managed to learn something entirely new about American golf courses during a recent trip to Myrtle Beach, South Carolina.

Apparently, Chinese-backed investors own over 20 golf courses along the so-called Grand Strand, a 60-mile strip of the state’s coastline. We’re talking about some of the most recognizable golf courses in the U.S. here.

In 2015, it seems, a group called Founders Group International bought further into the area for a total of 22 golf courses including:

  • Pine Lakes Country Club

  • TPC Myrtle Beach

  • Grande Dunes Resort Club

  • Several courses at Myrtle Beach National.

But Chinese investors went much further than that in their pursuit of American soil. They were once among the most aggressive buyers of our commercial real estate (CRE) across the board.

Whether this was simply to participate in the American dream or for more nefarious purposes isn’t something Wide Moat Daily is designed to explore. But the fact that those efforts have dramatically decreased over the last decade?

Now, that’s an investment question you might want to know about.

The great Chinese real estate retreat

Chinese investors have been interested in American real estate for decades. But they really ramped up their CRE efforts between 2010 and 2016, purchasing scores of residential developments, hotels, office towers, warehouses and, yes, golf courses, too.

In 2014, for instance, Anbang Insurance Group bought New York's iconic Waldorf Astoria hotel for about $1.95 billion. This is around the same time other Chinese-backed investors were busy acquiring all those Myrtle Beach golf courses.

And still others were committing billions of dollars to developments in New York as well as Los Angeles and San Francisco. In fact, according to Rhodium Group, Chinese foreign direct investment in the U.S peaked in 2016 at near $45 billion.

Yet that ended the very next year.

That’s when the Chinese government began reining in overseas investment and pressuring national businesses to reduce their debt. Add in a deteriorating relationship with the U.S. and then the pandemic, higher interest rates, and the ongoing crisis in China's domestic property market…

And the ensuing reversal was dramatic.

MSCI Real Assets figures show that Chinese-linked investors acquired only $2.06 billion worth of U.S. CRE between 2019 and 2023. Yet they sold $31.7 billion.

Admittedly, that last figure did include a major transaction involving Singapore-based GLP that had Chinese investor backing. But the broader trend was quite clear nonetheless.

American CRE just wasn’t as attractive to the Red Dragon or its business class anymore – a fact that continues today.

China embraces the American REIT

I’m sure the reason why is multifaceted. But there’s a good chance part of that retreat was because the Chinese government decided it needed all that capital propping up its own economy…

And its real estate.

Is it coincidence that, right in the middle of that 2019–2023 timeline, China decided to launch its own real estate investment trust (REIT) program?

American REITs, for their part, came about in 1960 when President Dwight D. Eisenhower signed them into law. Their purpose: to allow ordinary investors to participate in institutional-quality, income-producing CRE.

And while they’ve had their ups and downs since inception, American REITs have largely worked well in that regard. Today, numerous shopping center, apartment, warehouse, healthcare, casino, communications tower, and data center REITs – just to name a few types – continue to reward their shareholders through dividends and price appreciation alike.

They’ve had such success as a sector that they’ve even inspired dozens of other countries to follow suit. That list now includes China, even if there are some differences between their rules and ours.

The Chinese REIT program began in June 2021 when nine infrastructure companies ranging from toll roads to industrial parks, warehouses, and environmental plays went public. By this past September, that market included 89 listed companies across multiple sectors.

Source: Wide Moat Research through ChatGPT

Their combined original issuance value was RMB 241.6 billion, or roughly $34 billion in U.S. terms. And this all while China’s property sector is under tremendous financial pressure.

In many ways, that makes sense though. REITs open a way to monetize stabilized properties and recycle capital into additional investments. Instead of relying entirely on bank loans or asset sales, landowners can instead try to unlock value in the markets.

Source: Wide Moat Research through ChatGPT

A REIT structure doesn't create a wide moat

I co-authored The Intelligent REIT Investor: How to Build Wealth With Real Estate Investment Trusts in 2016. And since global publisher Wiley backed it, the book got translated into multiple languages around the world, including Chinese.

Source: Brad Thomas

I'm not suggesting it inspired China's adoption of REITs just five years later – though that is a fun thought – but it is fascinating to see the last decade’s worth of developments. And without a doubt, the investment principles my co-author and I covered are just as relevant to Chinese investors as to Americans.

But does that mean I’m ready to recommend Chinese REITs?

The answer is not really.

I’m definitely encouraged by China moving into the real estate investment trust space. And we could see significant developments from this rising sector in the future.

But investors need to remember that not all REITs are created equal, especially when looking at the global picture.

Each country naturally gets to dictate its own requirements for these vehicles. So anyone who does want to invest in Chinese REITs needs to familiarize themselves with all the rules.

It’s not always an outright apples-to-apples comparison.

More importantly, Wide Moat Research believes in looking at the quality of such businesses’ underlying real estate and the durability of their cash flow. We want to see strong competitive advantages such as scale, scarce locations, high replacement costs, and strong tenant relationships.

We also look for prudent leverage, disciplined management, sustainable distributions, and reasonable valuations. And Chinese REITs, from what I can see, still have some work to do in many of these areas.

Until they get that sorted out, I’ll stick with mainly American REITs – though only the ones that are proving they know what they’re doing.

Otherwise, I’ll pass on them, too.

Happy SWAN investing,

Brad Thomas
Editor, Wide Moat Daily