I’m old enough to remember when department stores were the centerpieces of American retail.

J.B. White. Sears. Montgomery Ward. They were all household names that families relied on for everything from clothing to furniture and appliances – and a whole lot in between.

As such, they had the potential to make their owners significant profits in the past.

There's a fascinating story along those lines in my hometown of Spartanburg, South Carolina. We’ve only ever had one billionaire here, to my knowledge: textile magnet Roger Milliken, owner of the exceptionally successful manufacturing business, Milliken & Company.

Though that wasn’t the only source of his wealth.

Back in 1914, dry goods wholesaler H.B. Claflin Company found itself in serious financial trouble despite its size and influence. And since the Milliken family was among its creditors, they got something out of the subsequent restructuring deal.

That’s how Mercantile Stores Company began, a conglomeration that included Southern-specific department stores such as Gayfers, Maison Blanche, and Castner Knott.

That allowed the Millikens to profit from not one but two important parts of the American commercial ecosystem: manufacturing and retail distribution. And while they probably only owned around 40% of Mercantile, that still gave them a nice cut when Dillard’s purchased the business in 1998 for around $3 billion.

That means they got around $1.2 billion in gross value before taxes and other adjustments.

Of course, that was before the e-commerce disruption that technically began in the 1990s and really took off in the 2010s. The retail world is much more complicated now, filled with smartphones and online opportunities galore.

So is there still a place for department stores to exist?

Simon Properties Group (SPG) says yes, there is. And the same goes for physical retail in general – even retail as big as department store-dependent malls.

Even Warren Buffett struggled with department stores

While it’s easy – and even accurate – to blame much of department stores’ 21st-century difficulties on e-commerce, that’s not the only factor to consider.

I’ve already shown how much money investors could make from them in the past. But none other than Warren Buffett proved how difficult these retailers can be to manage… even in their heyday.

In 1966, the legendary Oracle of Omaha purchased Diversified Retailing, an investment vehicle that included Baltimore-based department store Hochschild Kohn. It appeared inexpensive compared to its book value at the time. Plus, it involved seemingly attractive underlying real estate.

Yet, ultimately, Buffett made a mistake. As he admitted in his 1989 Berkshire Hathaway shareholder letter, he was lucky to finally offload it at about cost.

Moreover, that wasn’t his only negative brush with department stores. We can’t forget how involved he got in Sears as well.

That saga started in 2015, when hedge fund manager Eddie Lampert organized the spinoff of hundreds of Sears and Kmart properties into Seritage Growth Properties (SRG), a real estate investment trust (REIT). The new company was supposed to benefit from turning such buildings around for higher rents – a mandate that Buffett found intriguing.

So intriguing, in fact, that he personally bought 2 million shares of Seritage. That amounted to about 8% of its outstanding common stock at the time.

On top of that, Berkshire Hathaway set Seritage up with a secured lending facility in 2018 of up to $2 billion. The REIT was able to fully pay that off by July 2026, but Buffett himself definitely lost money on his shares as Sears fell apart before all our eyes.

If that can happen to the greatest investor of all time, it can clearly happen to anyone. Department store ownership in any form, put simply, is not for the faint of heart.

The billionaire family that knows malls

Again, that’s especially true today, considering these technology-heavy times we’re in. However, yet another band of billionaires show that it still can be done.

For those of you new to the mall REIT sector, meet the Simon family.

Their retail operations began in 1960 when brothers Melvin and Herbert recognized the retail potential in America’s expanding suburbs. So they started building and acquiring shopping centers in Indianapolis, Indiana, to take advantage of that secular trend.

Simon Property Group grew and grew from there until Melvin’s son, David, joined the business in 1990. He then helped it grow even more, including by taking it public just three years later.

Two years after that, he stepped into the role of CEO and began to turn the REIT into a global real estate powerhouse. Shareholders saw cumulative total returns of more than 4,500% from Simon’s IPO to David’s passing this past March.

The family business continues now under his son, Eli. So the Simons are clearly taking a different approach than the Millikens, who exited retail decades ago.

They’re also taking a different approach then Buffett with his attempt to profit off of distressed properties. The Simons’ modus operandi involves much more swanky assets and three competitive components:

  • Scale

  • Cost of capital

  • Technology.

And they’re making it work for everyone involved: themselves, their shareholders, and their tenants – department stores included. Other people wrote off malls years ago as one anchor tenant after another came under pressure.

But not Simon. It’s a master at keeping its industry relevant no matter what comes its way.

Simon’s triple-threat strategy

When it comes to scale, Simon owns some of America’s most productive malls and premium outlets. This gives it noteworthy leverage with the national retailers that want to rent from it.

If they want to benefit from the affluent demographics with established shopping patterns that Simon’s properties attract – in areas that are too built up to easily establish new malls – they have to play nice.

So they do.

Simon reported 96.5% occupancy this past quarter, with base minimum rent rising 6.1% to $62.75 per square foot. Meanwhile, retailer sales increased 14.8% to $852 per square foot, so I’m sure they’re not complaining very much.

As for cost of capital, Simon’s got that locked down, too. The REIT has an investment-grade credit rating of A from S&P Global and A3 from Moody’s; and it reported about $9 billion in liquidity in September.

That means banks, like tenants, are willing to work with Simon on its terms. The company can therefore redevelop properties and pursue acquisitions much more easily and cheaply than many of its peers.

Then there’s its ongoing embrace of technology. Instead of running away from the world wide web, the REIT is utilizing omnichannel opportunities to retain and even grow its relevance.

Its Simon Search platform, for example, helps shoppers find products across participating retailers. And it recently launched Simon Media Network as well to connect brands with consumers via digital advertising, consumer insights…

And Simon's physical shopping destinations as well.

Put that irreplaceable real estate, financial strength, and technological advancements together, and you’ve got quite the durable competitive advantage. Or, as I like to call it, an impressively wide moat.

A wonderful business, but not a bargain

Unfortunately for Simon investor want-to-bes out there, its shares currently reflect all that strength.

While many other REITs across varying sectors have struggled this year, Simon is in Mr. Market’s good graces. The stock is up around 27% year to date, even outperforming the S&P 500.

At about 17x its funds from operations (FFO), Simon is trading at an absolute premium to many of its REIT peers. And since management raised its 2026 FFO guidance yet again – its third time this year – and bumped Simon’s quarterly dividend to $2.30 per share, or $9.20 annually…

I don’t see this stock dropping in the near future. So I’m afraid I have to maintain my current Hold rating on this mall stock.

Even so, there’s always a chance. As I wrote yesterday, you never know what’s around the market corner.

With that in mind, I recommend waiting for a 10%–15% pullback from current levels. That would provide a more attractive margin of safety to own this otherwise stellar stock.

Happy SWAN investing,

Brad Thomas
Editor, Wide Moat Daily