Diversification has been on my mind a lot as of late. And with good reason.

Brad has said before that “diversification is the only free lunch on Wall Street.” By which he means it’s a free and easy way to reduce risk by spreading out your wealth across a wide variety of assets.

That way, if a single stock plummets unexpectedly… or if a heavily overweight sector within your portfolio falls out of favor… or if the local real estate market where you’ve invested tanks…

It won’t have an outsized impact on your overall wealth.

For years, I’ve been a single-stock investing kind of guy. In other words, I only held individual companies, not mutual funds or exchange-traded funds (ETFs) in my portfolio. And for years, this strategy treated me well.

However, the recent downfall of Jensen Haung has caused me to change my tune a bit.

Often called the “Godfather of AI,” Huang served as the global figurehead of Nvidia (NVDA), which he co-founded back in 1993. Running one of the world’s largest companies, he seemed practically invincible.

Yet clearly, that isn’t the case.

Otherwise, he wouldn’t have had multiple marital affairs, including one with an alleged Chinese spy. The U.S. wouldn’t be concerned about him leaking critical information to a foreign adversary. And he would still be leading Nvidia to further greatness.

Instead, shares were down by more than 31% during the past month, largely due to the Huang affair fallout.

It’s more than enough to make an investor think.

Why I’ve avoided ETFs

If you polled investors a couple months ago, I think the vast majority would have described Nvidia as the highest-quality company on earth. It was certainly making money hand over fist.

Even after Huang’s departure, in its most recent earnings report, Nvidia showed that it generated over 100% year-over-year growth on both the top and bottom lines with near 75% profit margins.

Frankly, those fundamentals are insane. And since past quarters have also been unbelievably impressive, the Huang scandal has been quite the shock.

It’s this kind of unpredictable event, black swan or otherwise, that makes diversification so very important. I’ve talked about this concept before myself. But I have to admit I’m looking at it in a whole new light considering how I’ve invested in Nvidia for so long.

Contrary to what I’ve believed for years, maybe taking the diversified exchange-traded fund (ETF) route is the safest path after all.

This is quite the statement for a value-oriented investor to make. I’m always paying very close attention to margin of safety when buying shares of a stock.

I work hard to analyze companies’ fundamentals to arrive at fair-value estimates. Then I wait for opportune moments to buy their stocks below that level.

Every percent that a stock falls below my fair-value estimate increases my margin of safety. And this, in turn, increases my long-term upside potential (via upward mean reversion) and decreases my downside risk.

After all, a stock that’s cheap should have less room to fall than a stock that’s irrationally overpriced. It’s Econ 101: buying low and selling high.

So it seemed equally obvious that ETFs weren’t the wisest play overall. They involve buying an entire basket of stocks regardless of valuation. Which means you’re throwing away a lot of potential profit in the process.

My ETF change of heart

Take an S&P 500 ETF, which includes the most expensive and least expensive stocks on that index all at once. You also get the stocks with the best and worst growth rates, and everything in between.

Maybe it was hubris on my part, but I thought I could accelerate my portfolio’s growth by picking and choosing the best stocks individually instead. I was essentially building my own, Nick-specific ETF of sorts: one that only included companies that fit my needs and met my standards.

And I had few objections to that strategy up until now. Since the market threw a Jensen Huang-style curveball at me, I’ve realized my stock-picking capabilities aren’t as infallible as I’d prefer.

Thankfully, I trimmed my NVDA position several times in the past. So I didn’t completely lose my shirt over the past few weeks.

But let’s just say I sure do wish Huang had stayed loyal to his wife. My brokerage account would look much better if he had.

The damage has been done though, and there’s nothing I can do to change it. I can only reassess my thinking now so I’m better positioned in the future.

That’s why I’m looking into low-cost, highly diversified ETFs like the ones below…

State Street SPDR S&P 500 Trust ETF (SPY)

This ETF tracks the S&P 500 index. In fact, it’s the original S&P 500 ETF with fund assets under management (AUM) of $756 billion – and the very first ETF listed in the U.S., debuting in 1993.

Since then, it’s generated 10.76% annualized returns.

The fund has 504 holdings, yields 1.01%, and provides market capitalization weighted exposure to the biggest and best companies in the U.S. Moreover, SPY’s gross expensive ratio is 0.09%. So while it’s not a completely “free lunch” to own SPY, investors are paying just $0.90 per year for every $1,000 invested in it.

Invesco S&P 500 Equal Weight ETF (RSP)

RSP also represents the 500 largest companies in the U.S. However, instead of being market-cap weighted, it’s an equal weighted fund.

This means investors have equal weighting to each of the S&P 500 companies, further enhancing diversification across the board. Established in 2003, RSP has produced annualized returns of 11.3% since then.

The ETF’s expense ratio is slightly higher at 0.20%. Therefore, relative to other ETFs on my list, RSP is expensive to own. Then again, paying $2.00 per $1,000 invested to have equal weighted exposure to the S&P 500 isn’t a bad price to pay for peace of mind.

Lastly, RSP has a higher dividend yield of 1.5%, making it more attractive to income investors looking for simultaneous safety.

The Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (VTI)

This Vanguard fund is market-cap weighted and includes not only S&P 500 companies but also medium- and small-cap U.S. stocks. With exposure to 3,511 companies, this basket provides a great picture of the overall national economy.

And it comes complete with an incredibly low expense ratio at just 0.03%.

Since inception in 2001, VTI has generated annualized gains of 9.38%. Plus, VTI yields 1.12% and sports a five-year dividend growth rate around 6%.

Vanguard Total World Index (VT)

VT, for its part, is built for those who truly seek diversification through both U.S. and international stocks. The fund owns shares of 10,158 different companies and tracks the FTSE Global All Cap Index.

In short, VT investors get access to the vast majority of publicly traded companies on Earth for a mere 0.06% expense ratio. VT yields 1.64% and has posted 8.65% annual returns since its inception in 2008.

Schwab US Dividend Equity ETF (SCHD)

SCHD is the largest U.S. dividend-oriented ETF with an AUM of approximately $118 billion. Tracking the Dow Jones US Dividend 100 Index, it yields 3.08% and has consistently posted double-digit dividend growth results.

This ETF seeks to own stocks that pay safe and reliable dividends, and exhibit "fundamental strength relative to their peers.” It’s found 102 of them that it deems fit to hold.

Its management rebalances the portfolio on a quarterly basis. And since its inception in 2011, SCHD has produced annualized total returns of 13.75%.

All of this comes with just 0.06% in annual fees. That’s not a bad price to pay for exposure to one of the most respected dividend growth portfolios in the world.

iShares Core Dividend Growth ETF (DGRO)

Finally, we have DGRO, which is similar to SCHD. However, the folks at Blackrock prioritize annual dividend growth streaks when selecting stocks.

Because of this, DGRO’s dividend yield is lower than SCHD’s at just 1.91%. Yet over the long-term, it’s likely that DGRO compounds its dividend at a faster rate.

The ETF tracks the Morningstar US Dividend Growth Index, has an AUM of $43.9 billion, provides investors with exposure to 390 U.S. stocks, and only costs 0.08% annually. Since inception in 2014, DGRO has generated total annualized returns of 11.96%.

My final thoughts on my ETF choices

To me, owning SCHD and DGRO together would create a very diversified dividend-oriented portfolio that’s managed by a couple of the largest financial institutions in the world. This makes for a quick and easy strategy to generate a growing passive income stream.

I now own both funds alongside VTI to provide exposure to non-dividend paying stocks.

As I get older and my life gets more complicated, I’ll be transitioning the majority of my holdings away from individual stocks and into low-cost ETFs like this. To me, it’s a low-stress way to build wealth while being able to allocate more and more of my time to my growing family.

Best wishes,

Nick Ward
Analyst, Wide Moat Research

Disclosure: Of the stocks discussed in today’s article, Nicholas Ward is long VTI, SCHD, and DGRO.